Title: The Battle of Dairy Cooperatives: A Struggle Like Developing Nations vs. Developed Nations
In the heartlands of rural India, the dairy industry is undergoing a seismic shift that mirrors the struggles faced by developing nations in their quest for economic progress. As we delve into the fierce battle between Amul and other dairy cooperatives, it becomes apparent that this isn’t just about milk—it’s a clash of ideologies, economic interests, and political power that could reshape the future of India’s dairy sector.
In the serene landscapes of Mandya district, farmers like Nanje Gowda have been forced to sell their cows and abandon dairy farming due to soaring feed costs and meager earnings. While Amul, India’s largest FMCG brand, is aggressively expanding its operations beyond its home state of Gujarat, tensions are brewing in regions where state cooperatives have long held sway. This expansion has become a contentious political issue and has ignited a fierce debate over the future of dairy farming in India.
Amul’s Managing Director, Jayen Mehta, has outlined ambitious plans to promote multi-state cooperatives and create hundreds of new dairy cooperatives in uncovered villages. While Amul’s remarkable success story makes it a force to be reckoned with, it begs the question: Why is Amul venturing into states where established local cooperatives already exist?
The answer lies in the inadequacies of many state-level dairy cooperatives. States like Uttar Pradesh, despite being among the largest milk producers, have failed to develop strong state-level brands, resulting in a fragmented dairy landscape. In contrast, smaller dairy brands have cropped up across the state, leading to inefficiencies and missed opportunities.
The cooperative dairy movement has faltered in some states due to political interference and ambitions. However, there remains a glimmer of hope in states like Bihar, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Karnataka, and Tamil Nadu. These states present lucrative opportunities for large dairy federations like the Gujarat Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation (GCMMF), the parent organization of Amul.
Amul’s strategy of entering states with weak dairy cooperatives and offering attractive prices to local farmers has ruffled feathers. For instance, Amul’s decision to supply milk and curd in Karnataka just before the assembly elections led to widespread protests and political upheaval.
The recent amendment to the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, which eases the merger of two state cooperatives, has further fueled political tensions. Opposition parties and cooperatives have voiced concerns about the potential loss of local dairy brands and have accused Amul of attempting to monopolize the market.
While the battle may seem to revolve around Amul’s entry into new markets, the real issue is the procurement of milk from other states. Tamil Nadu and Karnataka’s opposition to Amul’s procurement stems from the fear of their state cooperatives losing access to milk supplies, potentially leading to increased milk prices—a politically sensitive issue.
However, some experts argue that it’s only fair for farmers outside Gujarat to receive better prices for their milk. Amul has a track record of paying higher remunerations to farmers in other states where it procures milk, leveling the playing field.
As the political storm over milk procurement intensifies in poll-bound states, it’s essential for state cooperatives to enhance their processes, offer competitive prices, and streamline milk distribution efficiently. Failure to do so could jeopardize the well-organized and profitable GCMMF and leave India’s dairy sector in disarray.
In conclusion, the clash between Amul and other dairy cooperatives in India is more than just a corporate rivalry. It’s emblematic of the challenges faced by developing nations as they grapple with economic growth, political posturing, and the need to balance the interests of local farmers with those of national dairy giants. The outcome of this battle will not only shape the future of India’s dairy industry but also provide critical lessons in cooperative economics for the world to learn from.
Visit arjasrikanth.in for more insights.
SOCIAL PERSPECTIVES 